Proven somewhere is not the same as proven here

In a previous article, I argued that experimentation is not innovation. Experiments only create value when they reduce uncertainty and help a business make better decisions.

There is, however, another thing: Not every experiment starts from a blank sheet of paper.

Many of the ideas we encounter have already been proven somewhere else.

A particular business model has worked for other companies. A customer onboarding approach has delivered results. A software platform has helped organisations become more efficient. A prioritisation method has enabled teams to focus on what matters most.

The evidence already exists for elsewhere, but the question is whether it works here.

I dressmake, for myself and for fun, and I know that a commercial pattern is only a starting point. The design has already demonstrated that it can produce a successful garment. What remains uncertain is whether it will work for me.

Fit adjustments may be needed. Fabric choice matters. It may need adapting in accordance with the season I’m making for. The pattern is proven, but the outcome is not guaranteed.

Business ideas work in much the same way. The experiment is not whether the idea works at all, but rather whether it works here, and what adaptations are needed to make it fit.

  • A customer experience approach that succeeds in one organisation may fail in another because the customer base is different.

  • A software tool that transforms one business may create unnecessary complexity in another.

  • A business model that is highly profitable in one market may be impossible to sustain elsewhere.

This is where experimentation earns its place; not to prove the idea but to understand the fit.

 

 

Related Journal Insights

Previous
Previous

Stakeholder Management Is Not Just Communication

Next
Next

The Absence Of A Problem Is Not Evidence Of Permanence