Playing to win; Playing not to lose

I watch The Traitors - a lot - inevitably, I end up thinking about work.

One behaviour fascinates me. Some Faithful players manage to remain focused on actively trying to find the Traitors. Other Faithful players become almost entirely occupied with not being identified as a Traitor themselves - this tends to happen when they are accused and the real Traitors fan the flames of doubt and keep it alive for a sustained period. For the purposes of this article and thought experiment, I’m going to use this as an illustration of playing to win in the first instance, and playing not to lose win in the second.

Playing to win, to find the traitors, requires them to look outwards: What is happening? What have I observed? What doesn't add up? What has changed? What information haven't I considered yet? What assumptions am I making? What might I have got wrong?

If I am playing to win, I look for possibility. I experiment. I develop and organise knowledge and patterns. I consider and reconsider the shape of the game itself.

Playing not to lose, to not be perceived as a traitor, turns their attention inwards: Why did they say my name? Who voted for me? How do I prove I'm a Faithful? How do I explain what I said yesterday? What does everybody think of me?

If I am playing not to lose, I look for threats. I protect what I have. I minimise mistakes. I strengthen weaknesses. I respond to things that might hurt me.

Of course, if I am a Faithful being wrongly accused, I need to defend myself if I want to remain in the game, but once a Faithful player gets into that Playing-Not-To-Lose mode, it seems to change where they direct their attention. They stop investigating the game and start monitoring the threat to themselves.

  • Almost every new piece of information gets processed according to its relevance to their position.

  • Every conversation is interpreted according to whether it strengthens or threatens their own position.

They aren't really investigating the Traitors any more, they're managing the threat, and I think businesses can do exactly the same thing.

Playing not to lose narrows your field of vision. On The Traitors, playing not to lose can become strangely self-defeating. A Faithful who is under suspicion does need to defend themselves. But they also need to keep listening, observing, testing theories and noticing what is happening around them. The harder someone works to protect their own position, the harder they have to work to keep part of their attention on the game they are actually trying to win. The harder someone works to protect their own position, the less attention they have available for the thing they are actually supposed to be doing.

Businesses can make the same mistake. When a business is under pressure, some of its attention quite reasonably moves towards protecting what it already has:

  • Why aren't customers buying what we're offering?

  • How do we protect the things that are still working?

  • How do we get this back to where it was?

None of these are bad questions. They may be exactly the questions a business needs to ask. The danger is not asking defensive questions. The danger is allowing them to consume the whole field of vision.

None of them bad questions but they are defensive questions, and there is a danger that, like a Faithful desperately trying to prove they are Faithful, the business becomes so consumed by its immediate position that it stops properly observing the game around it. Defensiveness changes the direction of attention.

Like a Faithful defending themselves against a wrongful accusation, a business sometimes has to protect its position while simultaneously keeping its eyes and ears open. It has to respond to what is happening now without becoming so absorbed by the immediate threat that it stops observing what is changing around it.

Playing to win doesn't mean ignoring threats. It means dealing with them without allowing them to determine everything you pay attention to.

Sometimes the biggest risk isn't failing to defend what you have, it's becoming so busy defending it that you stop noticing the game has changed.

What's happening around us, and what might that mean for what we do next?

  • Customers are changing.

  • Technology is changing.

  • Competitors are doing different things.

  • People's expectations are shifting.

  • New possibilities are appearing.

If all your attention is occupied defending your current position, how much of that information can you actually take in? The challenge is to defend what needs defending while keeping enough attention available to observe, learn, question and adapt.

 

Related Journal Insights

Previous
Previous

How do you know if it’s not on fire?

Next
Next

From pathology to possibility